Here are a couple of charts to chew on.
The first is the WLI growth rate (Weekly Leading Index) from ECRI (Economic Cycle Research Institute). It leads business cycles by 10 months for peaks and 3 months for troughs. The second is the monthly SP500 with annotated WLI peaks and troughs.
In 7/99 the WLI peaked. Roughly 9 months later the markets topped in March 2000 (anticipating/coinciding roughly with the Q1 earnings in April). I don’t have the reports to tell when exactly they “called” the recession, but the WLI lead time coincides with the markets interpretation of the business cycle. The last bottom in the WLI came in 11/02 and the markets began rallying in 3/03 (about when they claim the business cycle should have turned up). So, during the last recession, the WLI peaks and troughs jibe rather nicely with the stock markets.
Currently, the WLI peaked in June of last year which would imply a peak in business growth in March-April of 2008. Judging by the turn in corporate profits in Q4, I’d say the WLI missed.
What I think is most interesting is to look at the points when the WLI started falling hard into negative territory. In 10/00, the WLI and the markets really broke down. It’s the same thing here in 11/07. This could be useful and is worth watching.
But as of yet, ECRI has not called the recession. The WLI growth rate is -7.9% and on the chart is at levels coinciding with the last recession. In fact, it’s very close to the bottom of the last recession! I just wonder how much longer they are going to mix words before they actually acknowledge this recession? And if/when they do figure it out, what good is their forecast when everyone is alreading figuring it out on their own? I thought these guys were supposed to be the best.
source:
http://www.businesscycle.com/(subscription required)